Skip to main content

Ethics - A quick overview of how I feel.

In short:
The study: Tell teachers some of their students are gifted (when they are not), and see if these students excel more academically on average.
Results: It would seem they do.
Ethical Implications: Yeah... about that..

A lot of studies have various ethical implications, which today go through incredible scrutiny to make sure we actually don't harm or impact the participant in any lasting way. It's reasonable, and in my opinion, necessary. However, let me point out the difficulty in having this system too. In education, we often want to learn what impacts participants and changes the way they learn to become smarter. However, for someone to become smarter, and learn more, you are inherently required to have a control group, which won't. That is always an issue. There are ways around it, and ways you can conduct the studies to put the control group in the experiment after you are done conducting data so that they both benefit, but for the most part, there's a line in ethics where you have to realize: If we don't cross it and become unethical, we may lose the value of a new understanding in learning. However, it's impractical to even try to measure understanding and weigh it against the effects you may have on the participant. The problem lies in that any experience can alter a participant in a way that a good lawyer could argue was harmful, and every single study that is planned can be argued to fail the ecological validity test because it is a scenario that is inherently planned, and therefore, does not mimic real life. So, what does all this skepticism and being devil's advocate leave us with?

Experiments are valuable. Experiments are the very reading of this article. Experiments are every step you take in life. You can conduct studies and discuss ethics, sure, go ahead. It will probably get you published and it has a lot of educational value because it takes true genius to create studies that conform to ethical standards and prove concepts about human behavior. However, it is human observation that will lead us beyond the significance of studies, because it is ecologically valid in its form, and although probably not externally valid to the entire human race, it is valuable to the culture that surrounds you. It was human observation that created the field of psychology, and it is primarily that which I believe will lead to the greatest discoveries about who we are, and how we behave.

Although I sort of veered off topic, to answer the ethical implications of the study, I do believe it was unethical for the other students who did not get the attention from the professor, but at the same time we understood that separation in our society and labeling has drastic impacts on the development of children. It would be impossible to conclude which was valued more, because you can't devalue humans and not care about their disadvantage, but at the same time the impacts of understanding what labeling can do has a huge impact on other human beings, so there's no real answer. But those are the implications.

Cheers,
Daniel.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Food: Volume 2

The Food Guide: Volume 2 August marked the start of my 10th year in Atlanta, Georgia. My first 3-4 years were arguably a waste in the context of visiting places (still remember being blown away when I first ventured into Decatur), but I wanted to revisit my Food Guide now that I have frequented many locations around Atlanta and found the pockets that I really love. Before I had structured the guide from cheap to expensive, but this time I will break it down by neighborhoods, since I think that better represents Atlanta. Disclaimer, I also love beer so some of these may be bias to the beer world. I explicitly won't be mentioning breweries or bars because this would just get insanely long, but hit up Hop City, and check out every brewery in town. I particularly have been loving the atmosphere at Atlanta Brewing Co. so go check them out! Updated lightly in January 2021 to add PERC Coffee, otherwise intact so forgive if anything is stale, and another update 5/10 I removed Le Fat

"I'm not the whisky you want, I'm the water you need." - Rupi Kaur

The light came through, Your peaceful smile, in truth. The surreal was still at bay But I did not know what my words would convey. I heard the silence pedal, I spent the days winning medals Hoping to protect my heart By covering it with metal. I'm trying to explain these walls, The shields and simple fears, I hope they don't reflect you away, But I do not know if you can stay. I buried myself deep within Behind this thick armor My wounds had frozen As I lay there, I burned the roses. A little heat was a sweet reminder Of my burnt past The loving pleasure and pain I ran from what would always remain. So when I glanced at you in disbelief, It was hard to mutter past my walls, But you saw past them with your own, By admitting what I had never known. The vulnerabilities we touch Let us know we are loved They acknowledge our shame And let us play our game With a silly smile, I finally got the courage I finally had the nerve, To yell past my wall

Building your passion.

This was inspired after I went to a SpokenWord event for the first time at JavaMonkey in Decatur. Loved the experience! Perhaps I was only dreaming, Only wishing that things would fall into place, That the blocks that scattered my mind would build an empire from the rubble, But deep inside, buried under this mess I knew those words that told me to stretch out, To reach out that hand and pick everything up. Piece by piece, I had to rebuild. Don't you tell me that your dreams have fallen, Don't you tell me that its been a waste, Because when you give up, that's it, That's all you've got. Sure there's a friend, a mother, and a brother, Sure there's the heart of compassion of others, But if your heart doesn't want it, Then don't expect it. I want you to take down every wall, Take down every word against you, Step on them and build a ladder, Make it to heavens, you are greatness. I believe in you, I believe in passion. Passion