Skip to main content

Reading Critique: How People Learn - Chapter 4

This chapter captivated my attention rather quickly as it illustrated how we can understand a lot more about children’s mental development by observing them with the assistance of others, as opposed to on their own. The understanding of every age range and the different mental and physical understandings of the world that we develop as we grow seemed to be somewhat excessive, and to be honest got a little scary at one point, given how much we know and can predict about our development. The understanding of this in depth growth in general understanding was complemented by an attempt to actually understand the differences between children and adults, and what mechanisms we go through to learn differently. Although some arguments have been made to state that our understanding increases due to our increased capacity to retain information, and/or our increased speed through which we can process information, the counter arguments provide interesting findings. A lot of children outdid adults in memorizing simple numbers by learning about strategies, mainly, chunking. It seems that what separates adults from children is not necessarily their capacity, but rather their experience and ability to develop better strategies in retaining information. However, this is still rather vague. How would you define the ability to develop better strategies? It seems that this ability comes directly from prior experiences, which are something which children can only gain with age. This is a claim that I felt the chapter should have made more vehemently. Experiences give us a greater ability to understand different scenarios, and learn newer strategies that allow us to deal with the present.

It was then that the chapter shocked me by stating the different ways that children learn given their understanding of intelligence (namely entity or incremental theories). This scared me because frankly, reviewing knowledge about children makes it incredibly frightening to have children and not constantly think about your every action affecting their development, because studies seem to show that it does. Other societies raise their children differently, as we saw through the apprenticeship model of the Pueblo Indian children. My concern kept rising throughout the chapter and it truly reached its high point when the role of questioning was discussed. It is somewhat of a controversial topic, as some societies encourage questioning whilst others heavily discourage it. This adds insurmountable amounts of pressure to how you decide to raise your children and what effect you will have on them. The chapter finishes off with stating two things, which lead my emotions in opposite directions. The first was that “early knowledge may impede later learning”. I shivered, as the first thought that came to my mind was that if you mess up, your child might not learn properly. But then, it stated that “they can learn practically anything by sheer will and effort”. I breathed out as the words of famous psychologist John Watson came into my mind, in his concepts of making a baby anything he desired through classical conditioning. It’s creepy to think that your actions will define the future of a human being, but then you realize that in your everyday life, you have an impact on the people around you, and you should always try to be that positive impact, because you can have an effect on everyone’s emotions, through every little thing that you do. Keep that in mind, and you will be a better human being.


Popular posts from this blog

My Barcelona Guide

Long overdue, but having been to Barcelona a number of times, I have been wanting to write some of the secret parts of the city that I encountered, and that are worth seeing. It's worth citing that a lot of the restaurants were originally gotten from an amazing list of restaurants my doctoral advisor shared with me, and that a lot of the places I love going to were first shown to me by our program director, who knows Barcelona better than anybody I know.

Additional note: Barcelona runs on a different time schedule than other countries. Dinner at 9-10pm is very common, and people start going out around midnight (to bars). Clubs start around 2am and go until about 6am, so keep that in mind as you enjoy the city. They also have afternoon naps (siestas), so in the early afternoon, a lot of things may be closed. The summer is usually pretty packed regardless because its booming with tourists. I generally do not like crowded toursit-filled areas, but you have to experience them once. You…

On nature's sincerity

I wish I could But I spoke nonsense I wrote it rather To speak it back to you.
The trees spoke quietly I looked from above and smiled The sun tucked away and I hoped It would spill its secrets.
The picture was rightfully painted Had I blinked, I would have missed it. Do not use sincerity It is not becoming of usage.
Learn to become And you will see the world As it was born It will smile once more. x

left it as a draft, came back, its ready.

Indemnify the asinine.
Take it back.
Make a profit.
It's just pocket change.

Don't wish, keep quiet,
and make it happen.
For preemptive boasting
Is definite fragility.

Don't let them shatter
your hidden incompetence.
Lay it on the table.
Serve it cold.

Realize that honesty
poisons the fearful.
Understand that truth
will tear down that wall.

Detail with actions
Step over those who detail
For substance is rare
But taking down the producer
That's the norm in this hell.